You sit down to write your memoir. Decades of memories swirl around as you stare at the blank screen or page. The sticky hot summer nights of your childhood, the day you walked in for your first job interview, the terrifying argument with your now ex-husband, the list goes on and on.
Each memory feels equally important. Each one vies for a place in your book.
You start writing. No outline. Before long you have forty pages of wonderful stories that don’t add up to anything.
Now what?
Does this sound familiar?
What’s missing?
The through-line of your life story.
I’ve been a ghostwriter for over twenty years, and I can tell you that finding the through-line of your life story is a vital step. Most new writers skip this, because, well, they never considered it.
What is the through-line of a life story?
Simply put, the through-line of a memoir is the lesson you learned as you lived your life; it’s told as a journey. It’s the invisible thread that connects the incidents of your book, and it’s the answer to the question, “What is this story really about?”
Notice I didn’t say, “What happened in your book?”
Those are two very different questions. What happened is the plot: you grew up in Ohio, you joined the Navy, you started a business, you raised three kids. What the story is about is something deeper. Maybe it’s about learning to trust yourself after a childhood spent pleasing others. Maybe it’s about discovering that home isn’t a place, it’s the people you choose.
The options are limitless.
Consider that the lesson is the arrival point, while the through-line is the lesson in motion.
This matters for a very practical reason. If all you have is the lesson, you’ll be tempted to write an essay that tells your readers the moral. That’s a huge no-no in literature. When you consider the through-line as a journey, you know exactly which scenes to write, because each scene shows you not yet knowing the lesson, resisting it, or finally earning it. It’s the cardinal rule of “show, don’t tell“ applied to your entire book.
Every memoir that stays with you has a through-line that resonated with you. When a reader finishes a great memoir and presses it into a friend’s hands saying, “You have to read this,” she isn’t recommending a collection of anecdotes. She’s recommending a journey with a beginning, a middle, and an end.
Why your memoir can’t succeed without one
You might think, “But my life didn’t follow a neat little thread. It was messy!” Of course it was. Everyone’s life is messy. That’s exactly why the through-line matters.
A memoir is not an autobiography. An autobiography covers your whole life, from cradle to present day. A memoir is a slice of your life, curated and shaped to tell one powerful story. The through-line is your carving tool. It tells you which memories belong in the book and which ones, however precious, belong in your journal instead.
When I begin my ghostwriting process with a new client, we spend our early conversations hunting for this thread, as it will help shape the outline, which will guide the first draft. Honestly, it would be a waste of my client’s money to do it any other way. Without a through-line, you don’t have an outline (your roadmap). You have a pile of random events that reads more like a photo album narrated aloud.
Readers feel the difference immediately.
Finding the through-line of your life story starts with your pivotal moments
So how do you find yours? Start by making a list of the five to ten moments that changed you. Not the biggest events of your life, mind you. The ones that had a dramatic effect.
This distinction trips up a lot of writers. Your wedding day might have been the happiest day of your life, but if you walked out of the church the same person who walked in, it isn’t a pivotal moment for your memoir. Meanwhile, a quiet Tuesday afternoon when a stranger said something that made you see the world differently? That might be the beating heart of your book.
Ask yourself: What do I know now that the younger version of me didn’t understand?
This path between who you were at the start of the book and who you are now is your through-line. Your memoir is simply the story of how you crossed that gap.
Write the one-sentence version
Here’s an exercise that might help you find your through-line: summarize your entire story in a single sentence. Not a paragraph. One sentence.
I’ll warn you, this is harder than it sounds.
Most people’s first attempt is something like, “It’s about my life growing up in Detroit and then moving to Florida and everything that happened with my family.” That’s a summary of events, not a story. Keep distilling. A true one-sentence through-line usually follows a shape like this:
A person who believed X went through Y and discovered Z.
For example: An immigrant who thought success meant erasing her accent built a business in a new country and discovered that her history was her greatest asset.
OR: A man who believed his father’s respect was tied to the family business lost the company in a fire and discovered his father’s pride in him didn’t burn with it.
See how much is packed into that sentence? Notice that the Z is your lesson learned. The through-line simply keeps that lesson attached to the journey that taught it.
Look for what keeps repeating
Sometimes the through-line of your life story hides in repetition. I worked with a client years ago who came to me with what she thought were disconnected stories: a difficult boss, a controlling relative, a business partner who took advantage of her. As she talked, the stories started flooding out, and a pattern emerged that she had never noticed. In every chapter of her life, she had handed her power to someone else. When we wrote her book together, she and I made sure that each chapter showed her taking back her power a little sooner than the time before. She was learning her lesson.
That was her through-line. Once we saw it, the whole book snapped into focus. Stories that had seemed random suddenly became stepping stones. The book practically outlined itself.
So look at your own life. Is there a lesson you had to learn three or four times before it stuck? A type of person you kept encountering? A choice you kept facing in different forms? Repetition can be a strong clue. Follow it.
Sometimes we need a little help
Are you the worst-positioned person to see your own through-line? I mean, you’re standing inside the story. It can be hard to spot.
Someone on the outside often spots the thread in minutes.
Invite a trusted friend or family member to coffee and tell them you’re working on your memoir. Share your list of pivotal points and ask, “What do you think my story is really about?”
They might have insights that will surprise you!
This is also, frankly, one of the great advantages of working with a professional. Whether you hire a ghostwriter, join a writing partnership, or work with a mentor, an experienced outside eye will hear connections in your stories that you’ve been too close to notice.
I’ve had clients gasp on the phone when a through-line surfaced. It’s one of my favorite moments in this work.
Test your through-line before you commit
Once you have a candidate, take it for a test drive before you build your whole book on it. A strong through-line passes three tests:
The sorting test. Pick ten random memories from your life. Can you quickly tell which ones belong in this book and which don’t? If the through-line helps you sort with confidence, it’s working. If everything still seems equally important, keep refining.
The stranger test. Would someone who has never met you care about this journey? Remember, your reader doesn’t know you (yet). She isn’t reading because the events happened to you; she’s reading because the journey speaks to something in her own life. A good through-line is personal in its details and universal in its shape.
The ending test. Does your through-line arrive somewhere? A journey needs a destination. If you’re still in the thick of the struggle and can’t yet say what you learned, it may not be time to write this particular memoir. That’s okay! Some stories need a few more years to ripen. (I share more thoughts on timing in my article about writing your life story now.)
One life, many through-lines
Here’s some good news: you don’t have to find the through-line of your life, because there might not be just one. Your life is rich enough to contain several books.
The story of your marriage and the story of your career may be two entirely different memoirs with two different through-lines. Trying to braid every thread into one book is how writers end up with 800-page manuscripts that don’t seem to connect.
To solve that, choose one journey for THIS book. Tell it beautifully. If readers love it, you can always write the next one.
Marketing tip: A series can sell well!
Additional articles you might find helpful:
How to Find Your Memoir Themes
0 Comments